Imagine standing in Times Square—throngs of people, flashing billboards, NYPD on every corner. It’s designated as a gun-free zone, promoted as a space of safety. But in the past year alone, Times Square has seen multiple violent incidents, including shootings and stabbings, even as one of the world’s most popular Gun-Free Zones.
It makes you wonder: are gun-free zones truly safe? Or are they a dangerous illusion that leaves good people defenseless while those with bad intentions ignore the signs?
This blog dives deep into the data, expert insights, and real-world examples to unpack whether gun-free zones prevent violence—or invite it. We’ll also explore how legal training, responsible gun ownership, and an understanding of self-defense law can truly make the difference.
What Are Gun-Free Zones?
Gun-free zones are locations where firearms are prohibited by law or policy—examples include schools, government buildings, and public transit. These zones aim to reduce the chance of gun violence by limiting who can carry a firearm. In New York State, many public spaces, including Times Square, are designated as “sensitive locations” under the Concealed Carry Improvement Act (CCIA).
But the question remains: do criminals and mass shooters respect these designations?
The Logic Behind Gun-Free Zones
Supporters of gun-free zones argue they:
- Create predictably safe environments
- Prevent accidental discharges
- Give law enforcement more control in public spaces
Yet opponents argue that gun-free zones only disarm those who follow the law—and create soft targets for those who don’t.
The Numbers: What the FBI and Crime Research Say
According to the Crime Prevention Research Center, between 1998 and 2015, 94% of mass public shootings occurred in gun-free zones. This finding suggests that such zones may not deter attackers—and may even attract them.
The FBI’s Active Shooter Reports show that most active shooter events end before police arrive, often within 5 minutes. If no one is lawfully armed at the scene, the delay in response can cost lives.
In contrast, incidents where armed civilians intervened had fewer casualties and faster resolutions.
Times Square: A Gun-Free Zone With Multiple Shootings
New York City’s Times Square is a textbook example of a gun-free zone. Yet recent headlines challenge its effectiveness:
- April 2025: A food vendor was shot during a dispute with a group of teens. (Fox News)
- February 2024: A 15-year-old suspect shot a tourist while shoplifting—facing no charges for violating the gun-free zone designation. (Gothamist)
These incidents suggest signs alone don’t stop determined attackers, although we must comply with the law.
May 2025: Connecticut Mall Shooting Highlights the Risks
On May 27, 2025, five people were injured during a shooting at the Brass Mill Center mall in Waterbury, Connecticut. The alleged shooter, 19-year-old Tajuan Washington, was out on $25,000 bond at the time of the incident (AP News, NY Post).
Authorities believe the shooting stemmed from a personal dispute—but once again, it happened in a location where guns are prohibited. This tragedy, like so many others, serves as a painful reminder that signs don’t stop bullets.
Let’s be clear: we never want to see anyone hurt or killed. Any loss of life, any human suffering, is tragic. But we must ask: how do we prevent these outcomes? Disarming law-abiding citizens doesn’t seem to be the answer.
Massad Ayoob: “Gun-Free Zones Are Hunting Preserves for Killers”
Legendary firearms expert Massad Ayoob has long criticized the gun-free zone model:
“Gun-free zones have thus become hunting preserves for psychopathic killers.”
Ayoob emphasizes that trained, lawful carriers are a crucial line of defense when law enforcement is minutes away. His argument aligns with the growing call for armed preparedness and personal responsibility.
Understanding the Law Is Critical
If you carry a firearm in New York, you must know your legal boundaries. Self-defense rights are defined under NY Penal Law Article 35, which outlines the justified use of force.
Our guide on Castle Doctrine in NY breaks down when and how force can be used legally in defense of your home. But public space defense carries stricter rules—especially in designated sensitive locations.
NY Safe Inc. Can Help You Be the Difference
At NY Safe Inc., we believe knowledge, preparation, and confidence are the best defense.
Our New York 18-Hour Concealed Carry Class covers:
- NY self-defense laws
- Situational awareness & de-escalation
- Defensive shooting techniques
We also offer:
We prepare everyday New Yorkers to carry legally, act responsibly, and defend themselves within the law.
Conclusion: Hope is Not a Plan
The dream behind gun-free zones is understandable—but the reality is often different. Statistics, expert insights, and real-world tragedies suggest these zones can create more risk than safety.
The choice isn’t between fear and aggression. It’s about knowledge, training, and the legal right to protect yourself and others.
Don’t wait for another news story to make you wonder: what if I had been there?
Take control. Know the law. Train smart.
Join our next Concealed Carry class and take the first step in being prepared.
Legal Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Always consult with a qualified attorney regarding firearms laws and self-defense rights in your jurisdiction.
No responses yet