Defensive Gun Use in Real Life — The Manchester NH Incident
On a cold January evening in 2023, the quiet of Manchester, New Hampshire, was shattered by a sudden act of violence outside Bunny’s Convenience Store on Elm Street. A man, later identified as Kyle Bisson, allegedly stabbed a stranger multiple times during an altercation, discarding the weapon into a storm drain before fleeing the scene (WMUR News). Amid the chaos, a concealed carry permit holder acted with calm and courage. Without firing a shot, this legally armed citizen used their presence, training, and legal firearm to stop the attack, provide aid to the victim, and ensure police located the suspect. This real-life defensive gun use (DGU) is a reminder of the power and responsibility that comes with concealed carry. It’s also a lesson in preparedness, legal awareness, and the importance of being the first to report any self-defense incident.
What Is Defensive Gun Use and Why It Matters
Defensive gun use refers to using a firearm to stop or prevent a violent crime. While mainstream media may spotlight mass shootings, studies show that legally armed citizens use guns defensively far more often—and usually without firing a shot.
How Common Is Defensive Gun Use?
- The National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS) reports roughly 60,000–70,000 defensive gun uses per year.
- In contrast, the Crime Prevention Research Center estimates up to 2.5 million DGUs annually, based on survey data.
The reality likely lies somewhere in between. Regardless, millions of Americans rely on their Second Amendment rights to defend themselves each year.
Most Defensive Gun Uses Don’t Involve Shooting
A key takeaway? The majority of DGUs end without a trigger pull. The presence of a gun—and the confidence to use it if needed—is often enough to de-escalate a dangerous situation. In the Manchester stabbing, the armed citizen did exactly that.
How to Report a Defensive Gun Use: Victim or Suspect?
If you carry a firearm for personal defense, you must understand this: when police arrive, you are either the victim or the suspect. And which one you are often depends on who called 911 first.
Be the First to Call 911
The Armed Citizens’ Legal Defense Network teaches that:
“The first person to call 911 is the victim. The second person is the suspect.”
If you defend yourself and let the attacker flee without calling, you leave yourself vulnerable. The criminal could call police and claim you were the aggressor—or a frightened bystander could misreport what happened.
What to Say to Dispatch
Keep your 911 call simple and focused:
- Identify yourself: “My name is [Your Name], I have a concealed carry permit.”
- State the incident: “There was an attempted stabbing. I stopped the threat.”
- Give your location and appearance.
- Request EMS if needed.
Then say, “I will cooperate fully after speaking with my attorney.” This isn’t about hiding anything—it’s about protecting yourself legally in the chaos that follows a defensive gun use.
Responsible Gun Ownership and Concealed Carry Preparedness
Carrying a firearm is a right—but it also requires training, awareness, and the right mindset.
Take the Right Firearm Safety and Training Classes
Start with a reputable concealed carry class. NY SAFE Inc. offers training aligned with New York State and multistate permit requirements:
- Why NY SAFE Inc.’s NY CCW Class Stands Above the Rest
- What to Expect: New York 18-Hour Pistol Permit Course
Know the Law: NY Self-Defense and Carry Laws
Legal use of force in New York is narrow and strictly enforced. Be sure you understand:
- Castle Doctrine in NY
- Gun-Free Zones: What You Need to Know
- How to Handle Police Encounters While Carrying
Stay Mentally Prepared
Beyond legal training, mindset matters. Learn the 4 Essential Rules of Gun Safety and always practice situational awareness.
Final Thoughts: A Real Defensive Gun Use in Manchester
The 2023 Manchester stabbing could have ended much worse. But thanks to a responsible, prepared concealed carry permit holder, a life may have been saved. This defensive gun use stands as a lesson in the power of good training and quick thinking.
If you carry concealed, train hard, know the law, and be ready—mentally and legally—to act. And remember: in any defensive encounter, make the call first.
Next Steps and Resources:
- NYC CCW Permit Application Guide
- Nassau County Pistol Permit Step-by-Step
- Suffolk County Pistol Permit Process
- What to Expect from the NY 18-Hour Course
Legal Disclaimer: The content of this article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Every self-defense encounter is unique, and applicable laws vary by jurisdiction. Always consult with a qualified attorney regarding the laws in your area and seek appropriate legal counsel if involved in any self-defense incident.
No responses yet