Self-defense isn’t just about what you do—it’s about what the law allows.
If you carry a firearm in New York, you’ve likely heard of the state’s Duty to Retreat law. But what does it really mean? And how does it compare to Stand Your Ground laws in states like Florida and Texas?
These aren’t just legal terms—they’re life-changing decisions in moments of crisis. The way you respond could save your life—or cost you your freedom.
In this blog post, we’ll break down New York’s unique position on the use of deadly force, explore how it differs from other states, and highlight court cases and news stories that illustrate the law in action. We’ll also explain how proper firearm training helps ensure you don’t just survive an encounter—but also the courtroom.
Keep reading to understand your rights, your risks, and your responsibilities.
What Is Duty to Retreat?
New York Penal Law Section 35.15 outlines when a person can use deadly physical force in self-defense. While the law does permit the use of force when facing a serious threat, it also imposes a significant condition:
“A person may not use deadly physical force if they know that they can with complete safety avoid the necessity of doing so by retreating.”
This means:
- If you’re in public and can safely walk or run away, the law requires you to retreat.
- If you’re in your own home, the law does not require retreat—this is sometimes called the “Castle Doctrine.”
Want to learn more about home defense? Read our detailed blog post on Castle Doctrine and Curtilage in NY.
What Is Stand Your Ground?
Stand Your Ground laws, enacted in over 25 states, remove the duty to retreat—even in public spaces. If someone threatens you with deadly force, you may meet it with deadly force without backing away.
Florida’s version, for example, gained national attention in the George Zimmerman case. There, the court found Zimmerman had no duty to retreat before using force.
The principle is simple: if you’re where you’re legally allowed to be and you are not the aggressor, you may stand your ground and defend yourself.
States with Stand Your Ground laws include:
- Florida
- Texas
- Georgia
- Arizona
- Kentucky
For concealed carriers who travel, it’s essential to understand which state laws apply. Our multi-state concealed carry classes help prepare you to stay legal across state lines.
Real-Life Case: Youssef Abdel-Gawad – Huntington Station, NY (2013)
Let’s bring this law into sharp focus. In 2013, 25-year-old Youssef Abdel-Gawad of Huntington Station fired at an attacker after the suspect had already fled his property.
Initially seen as a victim, Abdel-Gawad was later charged with reckless endangerment because the threat had retreated and he failed to de-escalate.
This case serves as a textbook example of what can go wrong when you pursue rather than protect.
Read more about this and related issues in our post on why you should never chase an attacker.
Why This Matters for Every NY Gun Owner
New York has some of the strictest self-defense laws in the nation. Just because you legally own and carry a firearm doesn’t mean you can use it freely.
Without a clear understanding of:
- When force is allowed
- When retreat is required
- What counts as imminent threat
…you risk legal consequences—even if you thought you were doing the right thing.
We cover these scenarios in-depth in our 18-hour NY CCW training course, which includes legal lectures, use-of-force scenarios, and live-fire range qualification.
Comparing Key Concepts: NY Duty To Retreat vs Stand Your Ground States
| Concept | New York Law (Duty to Retreat) | Stand Your Ground States |
|---|---|---|
| Must retreat in public? | Yes, if safely possible | No |
| Must retreat in your home? | No (Castle Doctrine applies) | No |
| Aggressor rights | Limited | Limited |
| Legal ambiguity | High | Lower |
This comparison highlights why out-of-state training often doesn’t prepare you for New York’s legal complexity.
Notable Court Cases Around the U.S.
1. People v. Goetz (NY, 1984):
Bernhard Goetz shot four men he believed were about to rob him on a subway. He was acquitted of attempted murder but convicted of illegal gun possession. This case remains a defining point in NY self-defense jurisprudence. Coverage of the case can be found in The New York Times.
2. State v. Zimmerman (FL, 2012):
The George Zimmerman case remains one of the most public Stand Your Ground cases. The legal defense hinged on Florida’s law permitting self-defense without retreat. NBC News covered the controversial trial and verdict.
3. Peterson v. Denver (CO, 2021):
In a Castle Doctrine state, Peterson was acquitted after fatally shooting an intruder in his garage. The jury found he was under imminent threat and had no duty to retreat.
Duty To Retreat: What If You’re Unsure in the Moment?
That’s the million-dollar question—and why training matters so much.
We teach all students at NY Safe that self-defense isn’t just about your firearm—it’s about:
- Situational awareness
- De-escalation tactics
- Understanding NY Penal Law 35
- And always calling the police immediately after a self-defense incident
Whether you fire a shot or not, your first responsibility once safe is to report the incident. Calling the police ensures your version of events is documented first. We cover this in depth in both our classroom and scenario-based trainings.
Our classes include scenario-based training where students role-play self-defense encounters. It’s one thing to know the law—it’s another to live through a simulation.
The Role of Prosecutors and NY Politics
In a Stand Your Ground state, a self-defense case may be dropped quickly. But in New York, even justified shootings can lead to charges, extended investigations, or civil lawsuits.
That’s why prominent instructors like Massad Ayoob stress that gun owners must prepare for the legal aftermath as much as the confrontation itself.
What NY Safe Inc. Recommends
Here’s what we believe for every lawful concealed carrier:
- Know your rights. Don’t guess—understand NY’s laws.
- Train regularly. Take legal, situational, and marksmanship training.
- Have a plan. Whether you’re at home, in public, or traveling, be ready.
- Don’t chase. Once the threat is over, your job is to live, not litigate.
- Call the police. Be the first to report the incident and control the narrative.
We can help. Our training programs combine legal education with real-world defensive mindset development.
Final Thoughts: Duty To Retreat vs Stand Your Ground – Fight Smart, Stay Free
If you own or carry a firearm in New York, it’s your responsibility to act within the law—even under pressure.
Don’t rely on instinct. Rely on education.
Because when adrenaline is high and lives are on the line, what you do next could define the rest of your life.
Learn more. Train smarter. Stay safe.
Legal Disclaimer
This blog post is provided for educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice. Firearms laws are complex and vary by location and circumstance. Always consult with a qualified attorney licensed in your jurisdiction before making decisions related to self-defense, firearm use, or legal compliance.
NY Safe Inc. is not responsible for any actions taken based on the information provided in this post. Participation in any class or reading our content does not establish an attorney-client relationship or legal immunity.
No responses yet